<a href="https://www.olark.com/site/3200-998-10-8434/contact" title="Contact us" target="_blank">Questions? Feedback?</a> powered by <a href="http://www.olark.com?welcome" title="Olark live chat software">Olark live chat software</a>

Serve Excellence with a Restaurant Mystery Shop

Female chef serving a platter of food

A restaurant mystery shop is a powerful tool that provides business owners with valuable customer knowledge. In such a fast-paced industry, your restaurant must operate in top shape to attract—and keep—customers. Additionally, with growing consumer expectations, you’ll want to be sure that your dining experience, service, and food quality meet their standards. 

So, how can you be sure your patrons get the accommodation they expect from your establishment?

By hiring a restaurant mystery shop evaluator, you’ll receive feedback from the customer’s point of view. You’ll be provided unbiased, actionable, accurate feedback in near real-time from several aspects of your restaurant. In sum, this data can then be used to improve your CX, refine your operational processes, and stay competitive.

Let’s dive into some key benefits of a restaurant mystery shop review and how you can reap all the tasty benefits.

How Does a Restaurant Mystery Shop Work?

In short, a mystery shop is a business review completed by a trained evaluator to assess various aspects of your restaurant. These undercover patrons will provide objective feedback and actionable insights that you can use to improve or refine your business.

For example, based on the program you choose, your evaluator will complete their assessment with your specific goals or with an industry-standard questionnaire. For instance, you might want an outside perspective on customer service expectations. As another option, you may be interested in a comparative analysis of your competition. By evaluating your establishment, you’ll gain an in-depth understanding of your customer experience and business processes. 

These evaluations can also uncover good business practices and define areas of improvement. In fact, there are multiple benefits to a restaurant mystery shop—and the outcome can help with long-term business success.

5 Benefits of Completing a Restaurant Mystery Shop

As previously mentioned, consumer expectations are higher than ever. To stay competitive and relevant, it’s vital to understand your business from your customer’s perspective. Whether you’re struggling with retaining customers or looking for ways to refine restaurant operations, a mystery shop can be precisely what you need. So, by identifying your strengths and weaknesses, you can maintain brand integrity and build long-term relationships. 

Let’s explore how. 

1: Assess Customer Service

Your employees represent your restaurant and directly affect the image of your brand. Thus, a restaurant mystery shop evaluation can give you invaluable insights into your customer service. You’ll learn what’s working and what’s not. Gaining an overall picture of the customer experience (CX) can empower you to make important business decisions and provide excellent service.

In short, there are several areas your restaurant mystery shop evaluator will review in regard to your customer service experience:

  • Employee Interaction and Performance
    • Retain knowledge of offerings
    • Offer upsell opportunities
    • Follow up with refills or checking on service

  • Service Wait Times
    • Wait time is provided up front
    • Customers can track their orders on a monitor
    • Patrons are notified of their completed orders

  • Laws and Company Standards
    • If you serve alcohol, IDs are checked
    • Company standards for preparing and serving food are followed
    • Health and safety regulations are correctly observed

2: Review Cleanliness and Hygiene Protocols

First impressions are crucial in whether a customer returns to your restaurant. In fact, this includes the appearance of your business in all aspects—from the outside surroundings to the interior counter and bathroom.

To that end, your restaurant mystery shop can provide insights from a customer’s perspective on your establishment:

  • Interior and Exterior Appearance
    • The entire establishment appears tidy and smells fresh, with no visible trash
    • Surfaces have been cleaned and disinfected
    • Products are stocked

  • Sanitation
    • Food prep and other areas are properly organized and sanitized
    • Hand-washing practices are followed before cooking and/or making orders
    • Employees wear hair and beard nets as needed
  • Signage
    • Hand washing signs
    • Inspection certifications
    • Proper restaurant and alcohol licensing information
    • Certificate of occupancy
    • Other safety and emergency information

3: Evaluate Food Quality and Consistency

In your restaurant, the food you serve your customers is—quite literally—your “bread and butter.” Therefore, it’s essential that everything you prepare is done at a high quality and with constant uniformity. Specifically, patrons will expect the same result every time they order their favorite dish.

For this reason, your restaurant mystery shop evaluator will review your offerings and provide you with actionable data about their orders:

  • Proper Preparation
    • Cooked to order, not undercooked or overcooked
    • Appropriate temperature on serving
    • Taste of the meal has good balance of flavor and/or texture
    • Ingredients are fresh
    • Meal is accurate to customer order

  • Consistent Quality
    • Uniformity between visits
    • Similar taste or portions to the rest of the menu
    • Cohesive menu offerings and descriptions

  • Portion Sizing and Presentation
    • Portions make sense to the order
    • Appearance and presentation are pleasing
    • Pricing makes sense

4: Compare Competitive Benefits

Having a constant stream of business is vital for a restaurant to survive. So, staying competitive can ensure that you keep current and potential customers interested. Basically, as you build your relationship with your customers, you can gain their long-term business, allowing you to thrive in a competitive market.

Obviously, your restaurant mystery shop evaluator can help you gain an understanding of your competition:

  • Comparable Service and Food Quality
    • High-quality dishes
    • Original, creative, or unique take on food
    • Consistent quality
  • Value and Differentiationsome text
    • Exclusive promotions or discounts
    • Seasonal favorites
    • Incentivized return visits with rewards
  • Other Competitive Insights
    • Great service and atmosphere
    • Superb customer engagement online and in person
    • Relevance with changing customer and industry trends

5: Enhance Brand Reputation

A strong and relevant company culture can attract customers who perceive your business as relatable. To clarify, your restaurant's reputation can help you build recognition and loyalty with new and current customers. By taking time to evaluate your reputation, you can reveal strengths and weaknesses that you can address to improve your CX. Of course, by investing in business evaluations, you show your customers that you’re committed to excellence.

Thus, it’s essential for your restaurant mystery shop expert to review and validate several aspects of your reputation:

  • Marketing and Displays
    • Engage customers with on-brand marketing
    • Ensure signage is cohesive and clear
    • Stick with verbiage that resonates with your audience
  • Online Presence and Social Media
    • Stay positive in engagements with customers
    • Respond to all reviews
    • Have a consistent online presence
  • Accurate Brand Reputation
    • Correct business information
    • Precise menu
    • Clear location directions

Do I Need a Restaurant Mystery Shop?

Now, even with all these benefits, you might be wondering if it’s still necessary to conduct a mystery shop evaluation. You might feel like it doesn’t make sense for your restaurant—and that’s okay. In other words, there are several reasons why a business analysis might not be necessary. 

Strong Company Culture

You’ve already spent a long time developing the culture of your brand and employees. Further, you created an open-door policy that your staff takes advantage of, meaning they feel comfortable sharing their concerns. You recognize that morale and customer interactions are at an all-time high. Because of this, you feel confident that your business is thriving, your employees are doing a great job, and there are no negative reviews that give you concern.

Return on Investment (ROI)

Alternatively, with the wide variety of benefits from mystery shopping, you may feel that it must be time-consuming to achieve. You’re a very busy business owner focused on refining your operations—and you don’t have time to manage a mystery shop program. On the other hand, the in-depth nature of evaluations gives you a sense that they are also expensive. After all, you always want to stay conscious of your budget. As a result, you don’t believe you have enough resources to balance out the advantages you’d get with an analysis. 

Consistent Internal Monitoring and Customer Feedback

Finally, it might not make sense to conduct a restaurant mystery shop because you already have team members who analyze your business operations. Plus, you might frequently have positive feedback. And even when a customer has a negative experience, you quickly respond and provide a solution to the situation.

A CX-on-Demand Alternative

If a restaurant mystery shop still sounds valuable to you, consider hiring an agency. CustomerOptix's CX on Demand is an innovative, cost-effective program with sustainable costs for the busy, budget-conscious business owner. You'll gain access to customer insights and high-quality, actionable recommendations from a team of experts. Certainly, you can create your program in as little as 10 minutes and focus on your specific needs as a restaurant owner.

Here’s how it works: 

  • Design your program with a ready-made template based on the restaurant and food service industry. Choose your budget by picking your form and evaluation preferences.

  • Customize your evaluation questionnaire with up to five additional questions, which are available in addition to the industry-specific preset questions. As another option, you can create a completely-custom evaluation.

  • Enter any locations that you’re interested in having evaluated. You’ll need to include relevant phone numbers, addresses, and the email address of the report recipients. Here, you can also choose your mystery shop frequency.

After your restaurant mystery shop evaluator completes their analysis, you’ll receive a report—typically within 72 business hours of the shop. The invaluable insights contained there will reveal any strengths and weaknesses in your restaurant. Moreover, these results will be essential as you move forward in refining your business strategies.

Undoubtedly, conducting a mystery shop is a valuable investment for any restaurant owner dedicated to consistently enhancing their operations and customer experience.

A Restaurant Mystery Shop Can Help You Deliver Exceptional Service

In a fast-paced and competitive industry, it’s crucial to understand your customers’ preferences and needs. Conducting a restaurant mystery shop gives you valuable insights into your business to aid you in refining your operations and reinforcing your strengths. That is, as you build relationships with your patrons and build a strong reputation, you’ll encourage customer loyalty. Furthermore, you’ll be able to elevate your dining experience, effectively boosting customer satisfaction and eventually growing your business.

To that end, are you ready to spice things up and take your restaurant’s customer experience up a notch?